Building agency for resilience and confidence
Learned helplessness in dogs: why giving your dog a say matters
Ever heard someone say their dog is as good as gold at the groomers? Stands there, doesn't flinch, lets them do anything.....
Sometimes that's a genuinely relaxed dog. Sometimes it's a dog who worked out a long time ago that nothing they do changes what happens to them. So they've stopped trying.
I'm Tanya, the behaviour consultant at Paw Patrol Training and Behaviour and a self confessed behaviour geek. This is one of those topics I could talk about all day, because it sits underneath so many of the cases we see. It's called agency, and once you understand it you'll start noticing it everywhere.
What is agency in dogs?
Agency is your dog's sense that what they do makes a difference to what happens to them.
If I move away, the scary thing stops. If I lick my lips and turn my head, my human notices and gives me a minute. If I sniff over there, I find the good stuff.
Think about the dentist who says "raise your hand if you need me to stop." Most of us never raise it. Yet knowing we could makes the whole appointment feel more bearable. Same drill, same chair. Your brain simply reads the situation differently because you've been given an exit.
Agency has two sides. Control over the bad means your dog can stop or avoid something unpleasant, like walking away when a nail trim gets too much. Control over the good means your dog can make nice things happen, like sniffing out a treat or choosing to come over for a fuss. Most people only ever think about the first one. The second is usually much easier to give.
The dogs who stopped trying
I'll be straight with you. The science behind learned helplessness has a grim history, and it involves dogs.
In the late 1960s, psychologists Martin Seligman, Steven Maier and Bruce Overmier ran a series of experiments. One group of dogs received electric shocks they could switch off by pressing a panel with their head. A second group received exactly the same shocks at exactly the same times, but nothing they did made any difference.
Later, all the dogs were moved into a new box where escape was easy. They only had to jump a barrier to the other side. The dogs who'd had control worked it out quickly. Most of the dogs who'd had none didn't even try. They lay down and waited for it to be over.
The researchers called this learned helplessness, and it went on to shape how we understand depression and trauma in people. Research like that would never get past an ethics board today, and quite right too. As a force free business it sits heavy with us. Those dogs left us a lesson, and we owe it to every dog since to use it well.
We see the same thing in humans all the time. Picture the colleague who stopped putting ideas forward after the twentieth one got ignored. Nobody calls that helplessness. They call it "not a team player". Dogs get the same unfair labels: stubborn, lazy, ignoring me. A shut down dog rarely looks distressed. They just look quiet.
The plot twist: control is what gets learned
Fifty years on, Maier and Seligman went back to their own theory armed with modern neuroscience, and found they'd had it the wrong way round.
Shutting down in the face of prolonged, inescapable stress appears to be the brain's default setting. What an animal actually has to learn is that it has control. When it discovers its actions work, an area called the medial prefrontal cortex kicks in and puts the brakes on the deeper stress and alarm systems.
I think of the prefrontal cortex as the sensible friend on a night out. When she's in the room, the drama gets handled. Having control is what gets her through the door.
Other studies built on this. Weiss found in 1971 that rats who could stop their shocks developed fewer stress ulcers than rats who received identical shocks with no control, so control shows up in the body as well as the behaviour. In 2006, Amat and colleagues showed that rats who'd experienced controllable stress first were protected against later stress, even stress they couldn't escape. And in 2007, Baratta and colleagues found uncontrollable stress made learned fears stronger, harder to undo and more likely to come back, while controllable stress did the opposite.
A bit of honesty from the behaviour geek: most of this brain research was done in rats, so we're borrowing it rather than proving it directly in dogs. The dog studies we do have point the same way.
What this means for your dog
Picture two dogs at the vet for the same injection on the same afternoon.
The first has never really had a say. Two or three homes, a long journey from abroad, held down for nail trims, told off for growling. At the vet they might freeze and "cope", which is really shutting down. Or, if their quiet signals have always been ignored, they might skip straight to the loud ones. Either way, the fear tends to stick.
The second dog has practised handling where they're allowed to walk away, and their signals get listened to at home. They still find the vet a bit worrying. That's normal. But they have a history of coping, so the brakes are already working, and they bounce back quicker.
The dog research backs this up. In a small pilot study in 2022, Wess and colleagues found dogs trained in cooperative care, where the dog volunteers for handling and can opt out, had lower heart rate measures during a vet examination and were easier to examine. In 2019, Willen and colleagues found fearful rescue dogs given daily enrichment built around time with a person showed less fear-related aggression and a more optimistic outlook.
Low agency hides in lots of everyday places: handling where a growl or a lip lick gets ignored, puppies plonked into busy classes with no way out, dogs who've been moved from home to home, a sudden attack by another dog, and noise like fireworks that seems to come from everywhere.
It also hides in force based training. When the only way to avoid a correction is to do less and less, a dog learns to do less and less. On a video that can look like the training worked. In reality you've got a dog with less agency than before, which makes fear stickier and future stress harder to handle. That's a big part of why we're force free, and why we won't rush a dog.
How to give your dog a say
Here's the good news. Agency is trainable. Think of it like a muscle, where every small win makes the next one a bit easier. We see this with our own clients: a dog improves in one area, then the next comes along quicker, and confidence starts to spread.
Give handling an opt out. Teach a simple "I'm ready" behaviour like a chin rest or nose touch. While your dog holds it, you brush or check a paw. If they move away, you stop, every single time.
Respect the small no. Lip licks, head turns and walking off should work. Then your dog never needs to shout.
Let them explore at their own pace. Games like Cardboard Chaos and Novelty Party let your dog decide when to get closer to something new. Nobody pushes.
Let their nose win. Find It and scatter feeding give your dog an easy, guaranteed success.
Hand over everyday choices. Offer two beds instead of one. Let them pick the route on a sniffy walk. Invite them over for a fuss rather than reaching in.
Tell them what's coming. Use a cue before you pick them up or clip the lead on. A predictable life is far easier to cope with.
If your dog is very shut down, go gently. Even an enthusiastic "come on, let's play" can feel like pressure to a dog with very low agency. Start with things that ask nothing of them, like scatter feeding, and let them come to you.
Get the free guide
Want the full picture? My free guide, Give Your Dog a Say, walks you through the science, the two dogs at the vet side by side, where agency goes missing and six practical ways to give it back. It's yours to keep.
Click Me
If your dog is shut down, reactive or just hates being handled, we'd love to help. At Paw Patrol Training and Behaviour we're force free, backed by science, and we always work at your dog's pace.
Start by filling in The Pawsibility Check and we'll take it from there.
Written by Tanya Hodgkiss, canine behaviour consultant at Paw Patrol Training and Behaviour.
References
Amat, J. et al. (2005) Medial prefrontal cortex determines how stressor controllability affects behavior and dorsal raphe nucleus. Nature Neuroscience, 8(3), 365-371.
Amat, J. et al. (2006) Previous experience with behavioral control over stress blocks the behavioral and dorsal raphe nucleus activating effects of later uncontrollable stress. Journal of Neuroscience, 26(51), 13264-13272.
Baratta, M. V. et al. (2007) Controllable versus uncontrollable stressors bi-directionally modulate conditioned but not innate fear. Neuroscience, 146(4), 1495-1503.
Maier, S. F. and Seligman, M. E. P. (2016) Learned helplessness at fifty: insights from neuroscience. Psychological Review, 123(4), 349-367.
Overmier, J. B. and Seligman, M. E. P. (1967) Effects of inescapable shock upon subsequent escape and avoidance responding. Journal of Comparative and Physiological Psychology, 63(1), 28-33.
Seligman, M. E. P. and Maier, S. F. (1967) Failure to escape traumatic shock. Journal of Experimental Psychology, 74(1), 1-9.
Weiss, J. M. (1971) Effects of coping behavior in different warning signal conditions on stress pathology in rats. Journal of Comparative and Physiological Psychology, 77(1), 1-13.
Wess, L. et al. (2022) Effect of cooperative care training on physiological parameters and compliance in dogs undergoing a veterinary examination: a pilot study. Applied Animal Behaviour Science, 250, 105615.
Willen, R. M., Schiml, P. A. and Hennessy, M. B. (2019) Enrichment centered on human interaction moderates fear-induced aggression and increases positive expectancy in fearful shelter dogs. Applied Animal Behaviour Science, 217, 57-62.




Comments